Audience - station inn copyright erie chapman 2014   A friend of mine was startled by what he found in his elementary school records. In third grade he was classified as "Disabled/Handicapped" & in need of "Special Education."

   Then he discovered that his IQ had been measured at 135 and he was listed as "Gifted." But, the school put him into remedial classes that included modules on "making paper airplanes." 

   He overcame this treatment to become a brilliant musician. He also teaches others including those whose gifts he is uniquely able to nurture. 

   What does society do with those of us who are "different?" Who determines the "norm" from which the rest of us are excluded?

   Across history the brilliant have often been punished. The disabled routinely suffer discrimination.

   Among the worst consequences come when brilliant people exhibit behavior that tosses them into some DSM 5 category of mental illness. Accordingly, they are pummeled, counseled & drugged out of their genius so that their "rough edges" can be honed to common taste. 

   The status quo is established & enforced by the majority. This is the group that Harry Potter's wizards think of as "Muggles." The Muggles are legion, the wizards are a distinct minority.  

   Occasionally, of course, the talented are rewarded, their uniqueness celebrated as life-changing. Many wizards suffered terribly as children, defined away from the norm by those uncomfortable with anyone who (like Robin Williams) is different.

   One of the strangest phenomena is the way we fight to conform as teenagers. Later we must break from that norm to accomplish anything "new."

   It takes astonishing persistence to achieve in a world that hates change & will only acknowledge success when "experts" affirm it. Would you really know The Mona Lisa was a masterpiece without expert confirmation? Why didn't the 19th century art world appreciate the brilliance of the Impressionists?

   Even the image I made of an audience (above) would make many uncomfortable. Why not take a "nomal" picture?

   When I came home from law school with a Martin Luther King "I Have a Dream" sticker on the bumper of my 1966 Mustang my father told me to remove it. "King is a radical," my dad said. When I refused saying he was a great man my father said, "Great men don't break the law."

   The opposite is true. The suffragettes routinely violated laws. How many rules did Jesus break? How often was Ghandi imprisoned?

   For every "different" person who persists to success their are tens of millions who suffer the calumny of the world because they are defined as abnormal. 

   It is hard to train caregivers not to discriminate against the drunk "Frequent Fliers" who stagger into our emergency rooms or the "Screamers" who, disoriented by drugs or dementia, cry out from our hospital rooms to tormenting ghosts.

   Amid a society that sorts by harsh standards some triumph. Only love offers compassion & help to those who suffer right now amid the shadows of bias. 

-Erie Chapman   

8 responses to “Days 254-258 – Being “Different””

  1. ~liz Wessel Avatar

    This dilemma seems like a double edged sword. Of course, society makes some rules to help keep order and to protect people for harm. Yet, so much of the time social mores stifle creativity. The impact is dramatic. Those who have the courage to speak up often pay a significant price. The consequence can be innovation and positive change or if a leader feels threatened the person might be ousted from the team. Often we become complacent and don’t want to rock the boat. In the work setting, group think can manifest. A first step is self-awareness. I see this fear-based thinking in myself more than I like to admit.
    It begins as children in our homes and schools. Kids may feel insecure about the messages they receive and in attempts to fit in can be quite cruel. For change to occur I think we need to change how we teach our children. I have seen some creative new methods for teaching children as catalysts for learning teamwork, creative problem-solving, compassion and conflict resolution. Unfortunately, this approach is an exception but it shows us that it can be done.
    My son was one who was “different” , not adept at the social skills of fitting in but he was and is an exceedingly gifted and a kind soul. I remember reading a story he wrote for an English class. He told of a group of young teenage guys and girls coming up to him at school and dumping their half-eaten lunches on the top of his head. He just stood there and did not run, did not fight just stood there and said nothing at all. It broke my heart. Yet, when I think about it now, perhaps his lack of reacting was an act of courage.
    Thank you, Erie for another thought provoking reflection and for your courage to be “differently” marvelously, you!

    Like

  2. julie laverdiere Avatar
    julie laverdiere

    Very thoughtful discussion, and very true. Lots of food for thought.

    Like

  3. sbeng Avatar
    sbeng

    Erie: thank you for this reflection. It is a reality regarding the society we live in today. People are “labelled and categorized”. Life for some people is already a struggle without being stigmatized. Thank goodness some has struggled hard to show that they are not what they are “labelled”, In our city we will have a new building where the “homeless” can go to and get their personal care needs met like taking a shower etc. There are good people that are kind and offer their help. Love is kind. As caregivers we need to have the “inner living water flowing from our being” as we attend to those who come across in our profession and meet both their inner and outward needs.

    Like

  4. ~liz Wessel Avatar

    I appreciate your view Suan, thank you

    Like

  5. ~liz Wessel Avatar

    For someone reason, I have continued to reflect upon your essay as well as my response all week. Finally, it comes down to this for me. What would our relationships be like if we could recognize our differences and do I dare say, accept and even celebrate them? Or perhaps, look beyond our differences to discover our common bond, the invisible thread that connects us all, the Source and Light of our being. If only we could recognize ourselves in each other.

    Like

  6. erie chapman Avatar
    erie chapman

    Thanks to each of your for your comments. Thanks also, Liz, for following up with more. Certainly, if the world followed you thread of wisdom – affirming the different instead of condemning them – society would thrive at a much higher level. Although things may be improving in the civilized world around this with much better protection for the physically and mentally disabled, it may ultimately be a matter of raw courage. To succeed in a world that pushes conformity, the “different” among us will always need to persist. The alternative is for them to stuff their true self and fall into a level of conformity that deprives everyone of their special gifts.

    Like

  7. Jonathan Ang Avatar
    Jonathan Ang

    When I was working at our university bookstore as a computer technician, I was paired up with another person who was very smart and highly skilled in working with computers. Even though he knew a lot more about computers than I did, the managers made me his supervisor due to my seniority and also because they wanted me to “keep him in check”. He was deemed different from the others because he talked differently, dressed differently, and had a different way of thinking. Working with him on a daily basis made me appreciate and respect him more as a person. He had brilliant ideas that people never thought of before but were often dismissed simply because it was not the standard way of doing things. It was too different. It was too radical. Unfortunately for the bookstore, he ended up leaving that job. More unfortunate, I believe, was that I was not able to support him more so that people would look pass his characteristics that made him different. As a leader, people oftentimes become too focused on maintaining the status quo and miss the positive deviant behaviors some may exhibit. I am learning to appreciate these behaviors and, hopefully, nurture them more instead of simply labeling them as “different”.

    Like

  8. Erie Chapman Foundation Avatar

    Thank you so much for your powerful story and your own insights on this, Jonathan. Your example is not only a great commentary on the challenge of being different but I fine reflection on your own growth as a loving leader. Congratulations.

    Like

Leave a comment