Harriet Walter - %22Mom%22 in Ted Lasso  The line, delivered on the popular show, Ted Lasso, rattled my soul. Not because it was new but because it struck at one of my worst weaknesses.

   The words came in an exchange between the show's female football team owner & her mother (Harriet Walter, pictured):

   "Why didn't you stand up to dad more?" the daughter challenges.

   "I thought it was better to be loving than right," the mom responds. 

   "I need to be right," you may be thinking. But, have you ever found yourself winning an argument only to be greeted with resentment?

   Loving relationships are never about one person being a winner & the other a loser.  Love & logic are antithetical. 

   Before being called to hospital leadership I was trial attorney. My success in court was exceptional. Maybe too much so.My courtroom goal was to win over a jury, not the opposing attorney. Outside court, such "winning" strains friendships. 

   Any attorney who has told his wife to, "Just answer yes or no," instantly discovers that lawyer's tactics are disastrous outside court.  Has anyone ever thought of you as loving when you say, "See, I was right!" 

   Caregivers often succumb to the trap of being "right" versus "loving." Making the right choices for patients can be crucial. Fear of being wrong haunts the conscientious. 

   What does Love advise? Arrogance is a form of bullying. The only way to be both loving and right is to practice both wisdom & kindness.   

   It begins if, amid every disagreement, I ask myself one question: Would I rather be loving or right? 

-Erie Chapman

Photograph: Film Still   

3 responses to ““Loving” or “Right”- Days 38-42”

  1. Liz Wessel Avatar
    Liz Wessel

    What a great question, Erie… I love that and a great question that can help to take a step back and breathe before responding.
    One additional thought that comes to mind for me is often our motivations may be good but when a conversation turns sudeenly crucial where you feel your heart beat fast or your face flush… motivations can change in a flash to I am right your wrong…that why asking that question can be so helpful…
    Thank you for your wisdom & kindness.

    Like

  2. Erie Chapman Foundation Avatar

    Thank you so much for adding this terrific observation, Liz. That’s it! You feel your heart racing. Simultaneously, your thought source makes a rapid retreat from the civilized part of you brain to the reptile brain at the back of your head. From there, nothing good comes out – even when you words are wrapped in a veneer of logic.

    Like

  3. Jolyon Avatar
    Jolyon

    This reminds me of the The Gospel Of Mary Magdalene in which Mary is describing knowledge that she received from Jesus to Paul and the the other disciples. Paul would have none of it because she was a woman and he did not hear it first from Jesus. Mary did not argue her point or knowledge. She loved her “Brothers” and moved on in Love.

    Like

Leave a comment