Bank Robbery - Chester RangeThis photograph portrays a 1974 armed bank robbery. Yes, the well-trained bank teller handled the assault calmly. Yes, both men were caught. Yes, I won convictions of both while serving as a federal prosecutor. 

Across three years as an assistant U.S. Attorney every case I saw involved theft of one kind or another: embezzlement, kidnapping, counterfeiting, attempted murder, bank robbery, extortion, explosives,  syndicated crime, drug offenses.

Although I only lost two of the thirty cases I tried it always seemed to me that the felons I prosecuted had suffered "thefts" of their own: their childhoods stolen by abuse or neglect or poor parenting. or, most commonly, growing up poor.

America's gardens of poverty grow crime. 

Thefts of life? There were 85 men & one woman on Tennessee's Death Row when I began ministering there. 100% of them were poor. Although rich people commit crimes I never had the chance to prosecute a single one. The wealthy hire the best lawyers. 

One of law school's core teachings is that a crime is defined as breaking  a written law. Other wrongs: auto accidents, malpractice broken contracts, for example, are resolved through civil lawsuits.

Too many leaders ask, "Is it legal?" Not, "Is it right.?" So many of  our worst wrongs are technically legal but morally wrong – including mistreatment of both the sick & their caregivers

In 1955 that Montgomery bus driver enforced a law when he ordered Rosa Parks to move to the back. Should whites have blocked blacks from coming to their churches or using their bathrooms because it was legal? No white hospital CEO or caregiver has ever been prosecuted for withholding medical care because of race. 

We need rules. Yet countless leaders have caused suffering by hiding behind laws, not choosing love. 

It is still happening. 

-Rev. Erie Chapman, M.T.S., J.D. 

3 responses to “Days 294-298 – Different Kinds of Theft”

  1. Terry Chapman Avatar
    Terry Chapman

    Legal vs. moral is a critical but seldom talked about way to make decisions at all levels of human endeavor. Most of us would agree that today’s federal government has made immoral decisions quite often, but not all would be considered illegal or a crime.
    Power corrupts over time and many prominent world leaders have fallen victim to this seemingly inescapable predicament. Let us pray for making America moral again! And; yes, so very many that commit crimes have endured abuse, poverty, homelessness and lack of solid parental love and caring. May we also pray that those numbers decrease with morality being our guiding light!

    Like

  2. ~liz Wessel Avatar

    This is a powerful yet heart wrenching essay, Erie. Thank you for shining a light that causes us to self examine our own prejudices that are sometimes more subtle yet equally problematic and important to recognize and acknowledge if we are to become more aware and change.
    It is very sad to contemplate how far we thought we had come, only to see the scab ripped off and to expose the deep prejudices in our country that is destructive and spreading like a virulent dis-ease.
    I am reminded of a thought provoking talk while attending a formation event with the Sister’s of St. Joseph, the enlightened but down to earth speaker, Carol Zinn CSJ shared that the underlying cause of all problems in our world is ultimately poverty (google her on YouTube).
    There are many forms of poverty in this world, I can’t help but wonder what comes to mind for readers?

    Like

  3. Todd Avatar
    Todd

    Such an important post Erie. I think about legal vs. Right/loving/moral often.
    What is kind?
    What is fair?
    What is right?
    What would love do?
    How would I want to be treated?
    How do they want to be treated?
    I’m still searching for the answer that will work for the masses,but right now I am focused on what I can do on my own every day and that is to “love by example”.

    Like

Leave a reply to Todd Cancel reply